What To Say When Calling an Online Buyer Lead

By Rêve Realtors

Our highly qualified agents are hand-selected because they too recognize the importance of relationships and transparency in our industry. We work with highly productive, full-time New Orleans agents – so you can be rest assured that you’re getting great service from a team who is committed to your success. Because your success is our success.

Calling an online buyer lead should not feel uncomfortable, yet for many agents, it does. You dial the number, they answer, and within seconds, the conversation feels stiff or rushed. Sometimes the lead goes quiet after that first call, leaving you wondering what went wrong.

In most cases, the problem is not the lead source. It is the approach.

Today’s buyers are more informed than ever. Before filling out an online form, they have already looked at listings, compared prices, and often clicked through several agent profiles. When you call, you are not starting the conversation. You are joining one that is already in progress. That’s why what you say, especially in the first few moments, matters so much.

Instead of trying to impress or qualify right away, the goal of the first call is simple: get to know each other. You want the buyer to feel comfortable, understood, and open to continuing the conversation. To do that, it helps to focus on a few core principles that consistently work in real conversations.

Here are three things to keep in mind when calling an online buyer lead:

1. Start the call with context, not credentials. Many agents open the call by introducing themselves and their role. While that feels polite, it often creates distance. Buyers respond better when you acknowledge what they just did and why you are reaching out.

Referencing the home they viewed or the information they requested immediately grounds the conversation. It reminds them why the call is relevant and makes it feel less like an interruption and more like a follow-up.

2. Ask questions that invite conversation. Once the call is open, it is tempting to jump straight into timelines, budgets, or financing. That approach often raises resistance. Early in the conversation, buyers are more comfortable answering simple, open-ended questions.

Asking what caught their attention, how long they have been looking, or what they are hoping to learn keeps the tone relaxed and conversational. These questions help you understand the buyer without making them feel evaluated.

3. Focus on earning the next conversation. The first call is not about closing a deal. It is about creating enough value and trust to continue the relationship. Offering to send relevant listings, explain local pricing trends, or share what buyers are experiencing right now positions you as a guide, not a salesperson. When buyers feel supported rather than pressured, they are far more likely to stay engaged.

If you want your online buyer lead calls to feel more natural and productive, refining this first conversation makes a noticeable difference.

If you would like to talk through what is working in our local market or get a second opinion on your buyer lead approach, feel free to call or reach out.

Conversations like these are where strong client relationships begin, and getting them right early makes everything else in the process smoother.

Clint LaCour
504-300-0700
Click here to schedule a call with me